| 1860 Albert W. Ferguson (1) | 1901 Henry B. Thielsen (25) | 1942 Jack Hatfield Murton (51) | 1983 Glendon Kale Jefferies (21) |
| 1861 John McCracken (3) | 1902 William A. Cleland (3) | 1943 Wayne Franklin Whealdon (42) | 1984 Lyle Robert Smith (33) |
| 1862 John McCracken (3) | 1903 Edward Wilbur Davis (20) | 1944 Ned Hunter Callaway (19) | 1985 Ivan Dale Rinck (10) |
| 1863 James R. Bayley (5) | 1904 Thomas F. Ryan (2) | 1945 Ned H. Callaway (19) | 1986 Steve R. Mead (1) |
| 1864 John C. Ainsworth (3) | 1905 Edward Biddle (17) | 1946 August J. Stange (9) | 1987 Lowell E. Amundson (42) |
| 1865 Cicero H. Lewis (3) | 1906 Lot L. Pearce (1) | 1947 Luke Fay Knowlton (3) | 1988 Alfred E. Maury (4) |
| 1866 George A. Edes (1) | 1907 Frederick Wm. Davis (20) | 1948 Horace E. Getz (35) | 1989 Robert Medill (10) |
| 1867 Benjamin F. Brown (1) | 1908 Albert H. Steiner (1) | 1949 Robert Edwards Dodge (21) | 1990 John Scott Harvey (9) |
| 1868 James R. Bayley (5) | 1909 Edward E. Kiddle (20) | 1950 Herbert Wm. White (18) | 1991 Arlie M. Thomason (49) |
| 1869 James R. Bayley (5) | 1910 Frank John Miller (8) | 1951 Floyd M. Edwards (5) | 1992 Vernon O. Munson (18) |
| 1870 James R. Bayley (5) | 1911 Charles J. Buchanan (2) | 1952 Vernon A. Turpin (32) | 1993 Robert V. Long (42) |
| 1871 James R. Bayley (5) | 1912 Oscar Hayter (17) | 1953 A. Ray Kellogg (3) | 1994 Herald E. Reid (23) |
| 1872 James R. Bayley (5) | 1913 Milton S. Woodcock (5) | 1954 Sprague Hanna Carter (23) | 1995 Otis C. Harden (10) |
| 1873 James R. Bayley (5) | 1914 Lewellyn C. Marshall (8) | 1955 Harold P. Patterson (7) | 1996 John H. Smith (22) |
| 1874 James R. Bayley (5) | 1915 Clyde Evans (18) | 1956 Lyman Crawford Palmer (10) | 1997 Roland E. "Gene" Wright Sr. (22) |
| 1875 James R. Bayley (5) | 1916 Septimus S. Spencer (10) | 1957 Aronah H. MacDonnell (16) | 1998 Carl George Carlson (4, 21) |
| 1876 John B. Lee (5) | 1917 Silas M. Yoran (10) | 1958 Daniel Lynn Woodson (18) | 1999 Richard A. Erath (49) |
| 1877 John B. Lee (5) | 1918 Max Bollack (2) | 1959 Samuel Allen Warg (31) | 2000 George L. Eldredge (8) |
| 1878 John Burke Congle (3) | 1919 James H. Richmond (18) | 1960 Harry James Young (55) | 2001 Dwayne Wm. Adams (57) |
| 1879 John Burke Congle (3) | 1920 Frank W. Settlemier (29) | 1961 Vilas Jay Brown (3) | 2002 Jerry Muceus (56) |
| 1880 David Patterson Mason (8) | 1921 Walter R. Bilyeu (8) | 1962 Simeon Harvey Sawyer (38) | 2003 Stanley C. Miller (1) |
| 1881 David Patterson Mason (8) | 1922 Frank M. Patterson (18) | 1963 Claude F. Sanders (49) | 2004 Larry O. Weaver (18) |
| 1882 James F. Robinson (10) | 1923 George Glanvil Brown (1) | 1964 Gene Caswell (19) | 2005 Robert R. Gedlick (20) |
| 1883 James F. Robinson (10) | 1924 Harry Wayne Stanard (19) | 1965 Glenn W. Smith (4) | 2006 Garrett K. Cooke (33) |
| 1884 Ferdinand N. Shurtleff (1) | 1925 John K. Kollock (3) | 1966 B. Neally Wood (42) | 2007 John P. Ridenour (53) |
| 1885 James K. Weatherford (1) | 1926 George E. Swafford (2) | 1967 Wallace E. White (41) | 2008 Daniel E. Crockett (53) |
| 1886 Wallace Baldwin (5) | 1927 Frank S. Baillie (15) | 1968 Charles G. Goold (31) | 2009 Gavin B. Reid (2) |
| 1887 Ralph F. Gibons (6) | 1928 Thomas Sims (29) | 1969 Paul W. Jones (26) | 2010 Paul A. Gehrman Jr. (34) |
| 1888 Thomas McF. Patton (1) | 1929 Herbert Lee Toney (16) | 1970 George W. Driskell (9) | 2011 Santino "Sam" Lupini (4) |
| 1889 Donald Mackey (3) | 1930 George T. Cochran (9) | 1971 George D. Robinson (10) | 2012 Richard E. Surroz (28) |
| 1890 Seth L. Pope (6) | 1931 Milton Latham Meyers (1) | 1972 Walter K. Belt (47) | 2013 Richard E. MacKinnon (29) |
| 1891 Jay Tuttle (11) | 1932 Donald Bruce Stuart (5) | 1973 Norman B. Hoard (56) | 2014 Dennis A. Stephens (18) |
| 1892 George E. Chamberlain (8) | 1933 Percy R. Kelly (8) | 1974 Ralph J. Huff (58) | 2015 Courtland "C.B." Brooks |
| 1893 George McD. Stroud (18) | 1934 Carl Wm. Evertsen (22) | 1975 Harry Edwin Dereiko (55) | 2016 Peter Stidd |
| 1894 William C. Crawford (5) | 1935 Lloyd Lytton Scott (3) | 1976 Howard W. Barnard (41) | 2017 David D. Fuller |
| 1895 John M. Hodson (10) | 1936 Ernest Paul Rands (2) | 1977 George Vernon Walker (2) | 2018 Loren Schrock |
| 1896 John H. Irvine (8) | 1937 Lewis Marshall Snow (42) | 1978 Vern G. Shipman (15) | 2019 Duane H. Hixson |
| 1897 L. Nelson Roney (10) | 1938 Clarence Roy Wheeler (15) | 1979 Lynn C. Lewis (48) | 2019-20 Kevin Gladysz Acting |
| 1898 Henry S. Strange (2) | 1939 Arthur Molesworth (3) | 1980 Richard J. Nelson (34) | |
| 1899 William T. Wright (20) | 1940 Andrew James McCallen (21) | 1981 Benjamin F. Wade (3) | |
| 1900 Orlando O. Hodson (16) | 1941 Bart Benjamin Bracchi (18) | 1982 Earl Lee Abbott (42) | |
